Alan Wald
Posted October 21, 2026

THE JOURNALIST AND editor Peter Beinart was invited to engage in a dialogue at the University of Michigan on October 19, 2026, on “Antisemitism, Islamophobia, and American Democracy.” The purpose was to “explore the intersection of law, humanity, morality, racism and bigotry and how we can use this knowledge to oppose the rise of fascism and dismantling of our civil rights and constitutionally protected freedoms.”
As soon as the event was announced, an attack was launched by “EndJewHatred,” an affiliate of “The Lawfare Project,” which uses lawsuits and legal pressure to target pro-Palestinian speech, campus activism, boycott, divestment, and sanctions (BDS) activities, and critical scholarship.
At first, dozens of identical letters from outside the university went to U-M administrators, Michigan legislators, federal officials, and others. These mischaracterized the presentation as a “one-voiced book event” denouncing “Jewish communal narratives”; they claimed that holding it in its current form, with its sponsors, would somehow violate Title VI of the Civil Rights Act (through discrimination against Jews) and would thereby threaten U-M’s tax-exempt status. Soon after, “EndJewHatred” circulated a notice urging people to click to send an email to U-M demanding a change to the Beinart talk (once again, mischaracterized) as an act of ending Jew-hatred, and, of course, urging donations to its organization.
Fortunately, the sponsors stood firm against this harassment and a well-attended talk and discussion occurred as planned. Alan Wald, an editor of Against the Current, a member of the Academic Council of Jewish Voice for Peace, and the H. Chandler Davis Collegiate Professor Emeritus at the University of Michigan who has published widely on Jewish American intellectuals, gave the following introduction to the talk.
Productive Disagreement

WHEN I FIRST started telling people that Peter Beinart was coming to the University of Michigan, and that I’d have the honor of introducing him, the reaction was immediate:
“Alan, don’t you know Beinart is controversial? Yeah, sure, Beinart makes people think. But he also makes them argue, and some of them even get angry!”
My response was: “Are you kidding? A room full of people disagreeing passionately about politics, Israel and Palestine, Jewish identity, and who’s misreading scripture? What’s controversial about that? It’s just like a typical Friday night Shabbat dinner was at my family’s house.”
Of course, Peter is controversial in many places. But before I explain why, let me describe the technique of his engaging in controversy. I see Peter’s method as a model for those of us who believe a university education means taking on even the hardest subjects without fear and doing it productively. Some call it “productive disagreement.”
As you know from publicity for this talk today, Peter is a professor of journalism and political science at the City University of New York. He is also editor-at-large of Jewish Currents, an opinion columnist for the New York Times, and a commentator for MSNOW and CNN. In other words, he’s a public intellectual constantly in conversation — on podcasts, in television and video interviews, and in formal debates. You can find them on YouTube and in the pages of many journals. His adversaries are often industrial strength: Alan Dershowitz, Bret Stephens, Coleman Hughes, Daniel Gordis, Elliott Abrams.
In these exchanges, Peter has a signature style. When he’s attacked personally — and some say he’s as dastardly as a Marvel Universe villain — Peter steers the conversation back to the political and ethical issues at stake.
More than once, he has been accused of standing outside the “true” Jewish community; there was even a call for a Beth Din — a rabbinical court — to excommunicate him. Through it all, he stays on the issue: human rights for Palestinians, and the policies most likely to bring security and justice to all the people of the region.
He listens before he speaks. He isn’t afraid to question himself, or even to publicly admit he’s been wrong. And unlike many people on both the Left and the Right, Peter knows the difference between serious, fact-based criticism and simply calling someone a traitor. He’s definitely not a candidate for the political purity Czar.
Who Is Peter Beinart?
So, who exactly is Peter Beinart, and how did he become such a distinctive figure in our contemporary political landscape? Answering that fully would take us on something like a luge ride through the entire history of Jewish American intellectual life. To be candid, I’d be overjoyed to do that this afternoon, since I’ve been studying the topic since graduate school. But time is short, so here’s the gist.

There’s a familiar pattern among the most celebrated public intellectuals in this tradition of the 20th century. In their teens and twenties, they left behind cultural worlds that were often narrowed by ghettoization and antisemitism, many embracing internationalist, multicultural, left-wing views. Then, over time, as career opportunities open, family obligations pile up, and hopes for social transformation go unrealized or are even betrayed, they recalibrate. They may insist they’re moving forward, but often they make peace with the status quo, adapt to nationalism and religious conservatism, and sometimes turn on the young people who are now as rebellious as they once were.
To be sure, none of the elite luminaries in the older pantheon of such public intellectuals—the Irving Kristols, the Norman Podhoretzes — fit the pattern as snugly as a lambskin Gucci glove. Some of those that one might call apostates even strike me more neo-nudnik than neo-con. But what intrigues me is the many ways that Peter’s path breaks the older mold. For decades he has been moving in a singular direction, sui generis as part of what might be called a counter-pantheon of later-life dissidents, rebels and heretics.
Peter grew up in a liberal family, not traditionally religious or observant—more Jewish by culture and historical identity. But they were deeply committed to human rights, departing South Africa for the United States in disgust at apartheid. By his twenties, though, Peter had turned toward Orthodox Judaism. In the 1990s he emerged as one of the “liberal hawks” at Martin Peretz’s New Republic, which he would go on to edit.
Now, it’s some 25 years afterward, and if you don’t remember exactly how “liberal hawk” differed from “neoconservative” (the two are often confused), one should read Peter’s 2006 book, The Good Fight: Why Liberals — and Only Liberals — Can Win the War on Terror and Make America Great Again. I purchased that as soon as it came out. I certainly didn’t expect to agree with it—a book reclaiming Cold War liberalism was about the last thing I wanted to see. But I read it to better understand those on the Left who thought differently from me. In the classroom and as a scholar, I’ve always urged that one should engage an opposing view through its most sophisticated advocates, not fringe fanatics and social-media edgelords.
Peter represented the best of the liberal hawks. Even when I gasped in horror at his foreign policy ideas, I learned a great deal from him. Still, everything I had studied about earlier Jewish intellectuals shaped by that Cold War outlook told me Peter would keep moving to the right. Instead, he stunned me with his 2010 book!
The Icarus Syndrome: A History of American Hubris was widely seen as an about-face after his support for the Iraq War — as a major repudiation of the assertive, imperial foreign policy he had once championed. That put him at odds with many of his former mentors at The New Republic, and their responses — a bit of an insult fest — are worth noting.
But this was nothing compared to the firestorms set off by his next two books: The Crisis of Zionism (2012) and Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza (2025).
A Change of Framework
The first, still written within the framework of liberal Zionism, was, in my view, not only engaging and arresting but prophetic. It recognized a widening gulf between young American Jews committed to liberal democracy and the hardline Israeli and American establishments that politically underwrote the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. I myself had supported a single democratic, multinational state in Israel-Palestine since the early 1970s.
But I had experienced so much isolation that I felt pre-condemned before I could get a word out, as if I were posting TikToks to no one. So, I was very curious what would come next.

After all, Peter was now in his early 40s, a CUNY professor, and the father of two children; he was at a stage in life when many intellectuals shift their Leftish politics Rightishly. Unexpectedly, over the next eight years, Peter changed even more dramatically — not just in his specific opinions but his framework.
On July 8, 2020, he published the New York Times essay, “For Israel and Palestine, Equality in a One-State Solution.” Not only had he broken firmly with the two-state paradigm, but he also next started using charged words like “apartheid” and, more recently, “genocide.”
Dayenu, I thought — it would have been enough! But Peter, with a critical but layered view of Zionism, went on to make not just the moral case for certain behavior as wrong; he also applied his analytical prowess to the policy case for how to accomplish things more justly.
By any metric, his 2025 book set off a worldwide uproar: polarization on steroids. Because the book came out after October 2023, when there ensued horrible civilian slaughter of both Jews and Palestinians, despite the undeniable asymmetry, there was much twisting and weaponizing of his language. Peter’s kindest critics called him a utopian with too little concern for Israel’s security.
And while most of the Left applauded Peter, not everyone was entirely satisfied. Some of us asked: is the central issue the moral failure of the Jewish state, or the 100-year war on Palestine? Does Peter focus too much on reckoning and redemption within the Jewish community, rather than on the broader movement for colonial liberation?
I’m sure Peter agrees with Left critics that long-term safety comes not through a fortress ethnostate but is built through multi-racial solidarity — horizontal alliances working alongside other minority or marginalized groups (including our Muslim brothers and sisters). And that Jewish safety will never come through the oppression of others.
But he has been questioned about his insistence on working within the Jewish establishment (one bonded to state power and the carceral state) to find some neutral common ground.
Feet in Two Camps
Well, if Peter’s goal was to provoke a major conversation, he has succeeded beyond my wildest imagination, and listening to all sides of that discussion is an indispensable education. For many, one object of fascination is the strange synergy Peter achieves by having feet in at least two camps — orthodox Judaism and progressive politics. Even a stone-cold atheist like myself was inspired to look again at the Tanakh and the Torah regarding his reading of “The Book of Esther” as a warning about revenge, and the view of “chosen” in “Exodus” — meaning not moral superiority but a burden to remember not to engage in oppression.
This afternoon, we have a presentation significantly new. Peter has previously addressed antisemitism and islamophobia, but not as a focused topic in a book or essay around the issue of democracy. I myself will be principally attentive to how he frames the two; how he defines them; and how they manifest comparatively in terms of historical roots in contrast to reactions to recent events. Also, in what he sees as the connection between the “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory and anti-immigrant scapegoating — and how they can be overcome through a common effort.


Leave a Reply